Category: Sudents and questions

Anyone can make a statement or ask about practice

  • The Six Worldly Councils

    The Six Worldly Councils

    The Six Worldly Councils: Explained by Dhammarato

    Across the six general councils (saṅgīti, literally “reciting together”), the preservation of the Buddha’s teachings repeatedly collided with human attachment to rules, wealth, political turmoil, and the belief in continuing existence.

    Council Approximate Date Location Key Figures & Patrons Catalyst Core Focus & Outcome
    First Council c. 486 BCE (Traditional) / c. 406 BCE (Modern research) Rājagaha (Rajgir, India) Mahākassapa, Ānanda, Upāli, 500 Arahants The Buddha’s death and a monk’s remark celebrating freedom from monastic rules Oral recitation and standardisation of the Dhamma (Suttas) and Vinaya over 3 months
    Second Council c. 386 / 306 BCE (100 years after the First) Vesālī (India) Senior Vinaya elders Dispute over whether accepting small coins violated the precept against gold and silver Debated monastic discipline (Vinaya); Dhammarato notes no rules were changed
    Third Council c. 250 BCE Pāṭaliputta (Patna, near Rājagaha) Emperor Ashoka, orthodox Arahants Mass ordination of 20,000 to 50,000 non-Buddhists seeking free food, robes, and lodging Entrance exam used to filter imposters; excluded monks formed the Mahāsaṅgha
    Fourth Council 1st Century BCE (c. 30 BCE) Āluvihāra (Sri Lanka) Sri Lankan Sangha Warfare in Sri Lanka threatening the survival of the oral tradition The Tipiṭaka was committed to writing on palm leaves
    Fifth Council 1868–1871 CE Mandalay (Burma / Myanmar) King Mindon, 500 Burmese monks Colonial pressure and regional wars in the 1860s The Pali Tipiṭaka (in Burmese script) was chiselled into 750+ marble tablets and verified over 2 years
    Sixth Council 1954–1956 CE Rangoon / Yangon (Burma / Myanmar) Mahāsi Sayādaw, Mingun Sayādaw, Bhikkhu Buddhadāsa Post-WWII turmoil and ongoing civil war in Burma International collaboration of 8 countries to recite and verify the Tipiṭaka; rebirth remained debated

    Pre-Council Context: The Last Days of the Buddha

    Before examining the First Council, Dhammarato frames the underlying tension of Buddhist history through events recorded in DN 16 (Mahāparinibbāna Sutta) and MN 38 (Mahātaṇhāsaṅkhaya Sutta):

    • Ānanda’s Subtle Confusion: Three months before passing away, the Buddha expressed dissatisfaction with his half-brother (cousin) and longtime attendant, Ānanda. Although Ānanda had served the Buddha for 25 years and possessed a phenomenal memory, he had not yet attained Arahantship. In DN 16, the Buddha drops repeated hints that one who has developed the four bases of psychic power (iddhipāda) could remain for the rest of the lifespan, which Ānanda fails to grasp.
    • The Belief in Continuing Existence: Dhammarato notes that Ānanda remained stuck in the subtle belief in “continuing existence” (bhava), or the sense that “I am Ānanda” continuing into the future. Dhammarato links this to MN 38, where Sāti, the fisherman’s son, claimed that consciousness wanders and transmigrates to experience the results of past deeds. The Buddha rebuked Sāti on the spot as a “foolish man” (moghamapurisa, transcribed as “Marga, son of an idiot”) without a shred of wisdom, teaching instead that consciousness arises dependently through present conditions.
    • The Buddha’s Passing (Parinibbāna): At age 80, the Buddha ate a final meal offered by Cunda the metalworker containing sūkaramaddava (which Dhammarato notes appears only once in the suttas and is often speculated to be mushrooms, while translators note it refers either to a mushroom dish or tender pork). The Buddha fell gravely ill for three days before dying in Kusinārā, explicitly instructing Ānanda that Cunda should not be blamed for his death.

    1. The First Council (c. 486 BCE traditional / c. 406 BCE modern research)

    • Pre-Council Context and the Buddha’s Passing: Three months before dying at age 80, the Buddha voiced dissatisfaction with his longtime attendant (and younger half-brother/cousin) Ānanda. Although Ānanda had a phenomenal memory, had served 20 years as an elected politician before striking a deal to be the Buddha’s permanent attendant, and double-checked everything Sāriputta taught him directly with the Buddha, he missed the Buddha’s repeated hints that his life was coming to an end. The Buddha finally stated directly that he was going to die, and later passed away three days after eating a final meal (often speculated to be mushrooms, as the Pali word appears only once in the suttas), while instructing the monks not to blame the cook or server because his death was simply due to circumstances.
    • The Catalyst: Immediately after the Buddha died, a monk went around celebrating that they were finally out from “under the thumb of the Buddha” and no longer had to follow his rules. Mahākassapa strongly disagreed and convened the First Council of “500” Arahants (a Pali idiom denoting a large, uncountable group rather than an exact number) to finalise the teachings so the Dhamma would not become diluted or “willy-nilly” in the future.
    • Ānanda’s Deficiency and Overnight Awakening: Mahākassapa initially banned Ānanda from the council because he was not yet an Arahant, still clinging to a subtle belief in “continuing existence” (the selfish notion of “I am Ānanda” persisting into the future, linked to rebirth). Desperate to enter the council, Ānanda practised all night intensely without success, finally gave up to go to bed, and right at the moment of letting go realised the truth, becoming an Arahant just in time to be admitted.
    • Proceedings and Outcome: For three months, the council focused on establishing what the Dhamma is. Mahākassapa questioned Ānanda, who recited the discourses from memory, establishing the Majjhima Nikāya, the Saṁyutta Nikāya, and much of the Aṅguttara Nikāya (which Dhammarato notes suffered from later additions and textual tampering).
    • Sutta and Canonical Cross-References:
      • DN 16 (Mahāparinibbānasutta) and Vinaya Kd 21 (Pañcasatikakkhandhaka) corroborate the Buddha surrendering his life force three months prior at the Cāpāla Shrine after Ānanda failed to pick up his hints, his final meal of sūkaramaddava (translated variously as mushrooms/truffles or tender pork) offered by Cunda the metalworker, and the old monk Subhadda celebrating the Buddha’s death as an excuse to abandon the rules, which directly motivated Mahākassapa to convene the First Council at Rājagaha.
      • MN 108 (Gopakamoggallānasutta) and DN 33 (Saṅgītisutta) explain that because the Buddha appointed no successor to rule the Saṅgha, the community relied on consensus and communal recitation (“reciting in concert” without dispute, modelled by Sāriputta in DN 33), with Mahākassapa leading the First Council, Ānanda reciting the Suttas, and Upāli reciting the Vinaya.
      • MN 38 (Mahātaṇhāsaṅkhayasutta) (transcribed as “Mahatanha Vibhavana Sutta”) is cited by Dhammarato to illustrate the error of continuing existence: in it, the Buddha rebukes Sāti, the fisherman’s son (“a fishy belief system”), as a foolish man (moghapurisa) for claiming that consciousness wanders from life to life experiencing the results of past deeds.
      • DN 33, AN 7.8 (Saṁyojanasutta), and AN 3.80 (Cūḷanikāsutta) confirm that “desire for continued existence” (bhavarāga) is one of the seven fetters binding a practitioner until Arahantship, while in AN 3.80 the Buddha defends Ānanda and predicts he will attain full extinguishment in this very life.

    2. The Second Council (c. 386 BCE / c. 306 BCE, ~100 years later)

    • The Catalyst and Core Controversy: Convened roughly a century after the First Council, the Second Council shifted focus from the Dhamma to the Vinaya (monastic rules and their application). The central dispute revolved around money, specifically whether the precept against accepting gold and silver (jātarūpa-rajata) forbade monks from accepting small everyday coinage.
    • Dhammarato’s Linguistic and Historical Analysis: Pointing out that archaeological digs from that era reveal coins made of copper, tin, brass, or brass-covered wood rather than precious metals, Dhammarato explains that jātarūpa (silver, root of “rupee”) and rajata (or Thai thong, gold) referred to bullion. He notes that the Buddha opposed the accumulation of genuine wealth (bullion, land, cattle, goats, sheep, servants, and slaves), not petty change. He illustrates how this debate persists today with two Thai anecdotes: receiving a traditional birthday offering of 47 baht (~$1.50) in coins at Wat Cholapratan in Nonthaburi, and a famous Bangkok monk who died with bags of birthday alms stacked along his kuti walls totalling under 20,000 baht (~$600), sparking a national newspaper scandal until people realised how small the amount actually was.
    • Proceedings and Outcome: In Dhammarato’s telling, the Second Council ended in a complete stalemate (“a hilarious joke”) because the monks could not agree on how much money was too much, leaving the Vinaya completely unchanged from the time of the Buddha.
    • Sutta and Canonical Cross-References:
      • Vinaya Kd 22 (Sattasatikakkhandhaka) and Bu NP 18 record the Second Council at Vesālī as a confrontation between “rigorists” (monks from Pāvā, Avanti, and the south) and “laxists” (monks from Vesālī) over ten points of discipline, the foremost being the acceptance of money (jātarūparajata, defined in Nissaggiya Pācittiya 18 as currency of any kind). The council ruled in favour of the rigorists on all ten points, affirming the original Vinaya without adding or abolishing a single rule (upholding the Buddha’s non-decline principle in DN 16 and AN 7.23).
      • DN 1 (Brahmajālasutta) and DN 2 (Sāmaññaphalasutta) match the sutta passage Dhammarato references regarding worldly wealth, detailing how a mendicant abstains from accepting gold and silver, raw grain, bondservants, sheep and goats, pigs, cattle, horses, and fields and land.

    3. The Third Council (c. 250 BCE)

    • Historical Context and Ashoka’s Pillars: Held during the reign of Emperor Ashoka, whose grandfather (Chandragupta Maurya) and father (Bindusāra) had fought Alexander the Great’s forces and unified almost all of India (except Tamil Nadu and Kerala in the deep south). Ashoka erected stone pillars chiselled with Dhamma phrases across his empire, which Dhammarato highlights as concrete proof that the Dhamma was written down long before the Fourth Council (and likely even during the Buddha’s lifetime).
    • The Catalyst: Ashoka was a “gung-ho patron” who made ordaining as a monk overly easy by providing free robes, bowls, monastery rooms, and medicine. Between 20,000 and 50,000 people ordained for the material benefits, including Hindu swamis and rishis, completely overwhelming the genuine Arahants and teachers (“Ashoka didn’t do Buddhism any favour at all”).
    • Proceedings, Entrance Exam, and the Mahāsaṅgha Schism: Convened in Pāṭaliputta (transcribed as “Patagonia”), near Rājagaha (“Rajgiri”), the council instituted an entrance exam: only monks who could answer questions about what the Buddha actually taught were allowed inside. Because Ashoka hosted the council in his home district where the unawakened monks were concentrated, the excluded majority held their own rival assembly called the Mahāsaṅgha (Mahāsāṅghika).
    • Outcome and Textual Pollution: While the inner council re-established the authentic Dhamma, Dhammarato identifies the excluded Mahāsaṅgha as the birth of Mahāyāna Buddhism, heavily polluted with Hindu philosophy and magical beliefs. He also notes that new texts (such as the Dhammapada) were composed during this era using magical themes to entice Hindus to convert, making mainstream Buddhism look like “just another form of Hinduism.”
    • Sutta and Canonical Cross-References:
      • DN 1 (Brahmajālasutta), DN 16, and MN 52 (Aṭṭhakanāgarasutta) notes and commentaries confirm that after the Mauryan dynasty (founded by Chandragupta, Bindusāra, and Ashoka) unified India, lavish state patronage in Pāṭaliputta attracted so many corrupt imposters seeking material profits that the Third Council had to be held to expel them, an event historically linked to placing DN 1 (The Prime Net) at the start of the Dīgha Nikāya to screen out wrong views.

    4. The Fourth Council (1st Century BCE)

    • Location and Catalyst: Convened in Sri Lanka during a time of “downright warfare” (while Buddhism remained strong in India). Fearing that the authentic teachings were in danger of being wiped out amid the conflict, Sri Lankan monks organised a council to safeguard the canon.
    • Proceedings and Outcome: The monks gathered the oral teachings and committed them to writing on palm leaves (or banana leaves). While Sri Lankan tradition claims this was the first time the Dhamma was ever written down, Dhammarato points back to Ashoka’s inscribed pillars 250 years earlier as proof that written Dhamma already existed.
    • Sutta and Canonical Cross-References:
      • Pali Textual History confirms that the Theravāda Tipiṭaka was transmitted orally by generations of monastic reciters until around 30 BCE (1st century BCE), when it was first written down on palm-leaf manuscripts at the Āluvihāra monastery in Sri Lanka.

    5. The Fifth Council (1868 to 1871 CE)

    • Location and Catalyst: Held in Mandalay (“Mandala”), Burma, under the patronage of King Mindon (“King Mongdong”) during a decade of widespread global warfare in the 1860s (including British colonial expansion, European wars, and the American Civil War).
    • Proceedings and the Marble Tablets: King Mindon collected the entire Pali Tipiṭaka (written in Burmese script) and had it chiselled into more than 750 marble tablets (completed around 1868). From 1868 to 1871, a council of about 500 monks spent two years reviewing the stone carvings, making only one or two minor changes before sanctifying the text. Dhammarato notes that when the British later invaded Mandalay, they looted all the gold and silver (even stealing an Anāgāmi’s golden casket), but left the 750+ marble tablets intact because marble was too heavy to ship back to London.
    • Lineage and Regional Context: Dhammarato points out that despite fighting a major war a century earlier, Thailand and Burma were close friends in the 1860s. He connects this period to King Mongkut of Thailand (who spent 24 years as a monk before reigning from ~1850 to 1868 and fathering 47 children, including King Chulalongkorn and Prince Vajirañāṇavarorasa). Through Vajirañāṇavarorasa and his student Somdet Phra Saṅgharāja Pussadeva (“Bhuddhagosa Jarn”) down to Bhikkhu Buddhadāsa, Dhammarato traces his own Thai monastic lineage back to roughly 1804.

    6. The Sixth Council (Late 1954 to Early 1956 CE)

    • Location, Catalyst, and International Scope: Convened in Rangoon (Yangon), Burma, in response to post-WWII turmoil and ongoing civil war in Burma (which began when the British left in the late 1940s, a conflict Dhammarato notes also drove the invention of the Burmese Vipassanā movement popularised by S.N. Goenka). The council was organised internationally with representatives from eight countries: Sri Lanka, Nepal, India, Burma, Thailand, Laos, Cambodia, and Vietnam.
    • Bhikkhu Buddhadāsa’s Role: Bhikkhu Buddhadāsa led the Thai delegation into the council and delivered a keynote address calling on the assembly to preserve the authentic, liberating Dhamma stripped of metaphysical speculation (his untranslated Thai speech is preserved in the Buddhist archives in Bangkok, alongside letters to his teacher at Wat Pathum Wanaram).
    • Proceedings and Feats of Memorisation: Modelled as a direct reenactment of the First Council, Mahāsi Sayādaw took on the role of Mahākassapa (asking the questions), and Mingun Sayādaw (“Mungun Savadaw”) took on the role of Ānanda (answering), having memorised and recited the entire Burmese Tipiṭaka from memory in front of the assembly. Meanwhile, delegations from other countries (such as Thailand, represented by master chanters trained at Wat Pho in Bangkok, including a companion of Buddhadāsa who trained Dhammarato’s friend Abbot Mahāomsin of Wat Greensboro) chanted their own national editions of the Pali Tipiṭaka in separate rooms.
    • Core Controversy and Outcome: Just as Ānanda struggled with the belief in “continuing existence” prior to the First Council, the number one controversy at the Sixth Council remained rebirth and continuing existence, which ended with no resolution because participants refused to let go of their cherished beliefs.

    Synthesis: Continuing Existence and the Four Imponderables

    Dhammarato ties the entire chronology of the Six Councils back to why the controversy over rebirth and kamma is a distraction from the Buddha’s core teaching (dukkha and dukkha-nirodha, or “don’t worry, be happy”):

    1. Reincarnation vs. Rebirth: He distinguishes the Hindu view of reincarnation (that a permanent “you” or consciousness returns after death, which the Buddha rebuked in MN 38) from the modern Buddhist rationalisation of rebirth (that “something” inherits kamma, but it isn’t “you”). Dhammarato points out that if the future inheritor is not you, and you are constantly changing (anicca), then you right now are not even the inheritor of the old you from the past, making past and future lives completely irrelevant to present practice.
    2. The Four Imponderables (Acinteyya Sutta, AN 4.77): In answering questions at the end of the talk, Dhammarato explains why pondering these metaphysical questions only creates dissatisfaction:
      • The results of Kamma (actions): You cannot know the full future value or complex causal chain of an action in advance; the result in the present moment is what determines whether an action was workable or not.
      • The extent of the mind of a Buddha: An ordinary, dissatisfied mind cannot conceptualise what liberation is like without experiencing it directly.
      • The extent of Jhāna (the human mind): You cannot know the full capacity of the human mind or meditative states through speculation, only through direct experience.
      • The origin and future of the world: Nobody knows how the universe started (such as the Big Bang) or what will happen in the future (such as whether there will be a Seventh Council), because we are simply “plopped into the middle of it, right here, right now.”

    Views: 4

  • False Dhamma teaching and fake monks

    I have noticed of late several “monks” spreading very strange teachings online. Upon investigation, I have found no lineage, no ordination, and almost zero qualifications re. Dhamma. And yet they have managed to penetrate quite deeply into the upper echelons of monastic life. One such person is a man going by the name of Ajahn Tri Dao, who has become wildly popular on TikTok, is not affiliated with any sangha or monastery, is not ordained, and seems to be teaching concepts very far removed from the canon. Another is someone called Vasu Bandhu (the name says it all).  Have you heard of these people? Should we just keep quiet and let these people be?

    kind regards,

    CM Long

    Views: 2

  • The Supreme Teacher

    The Supreme Teacher

    The Supreme Teacher is our own EVALUATION, described & explained by the Buddha & His Sangha.
    —
    The Teaching can be found in the Suttas and its basis is made by peace of mind coming from Mindfulness, that allows right Evaluation.

    Right Evaluation means that Discernment grows and Wisdom increases.

    Knowing how things really are takes to more Mindfulness and deeper Concentration, that, together, take to better Discernment.

    As anyone can see, the Effort in the practice is personal, a Teacher only points the way, explains how to walk that way, how to overcome obstacles found on it and what its result is.

    From our side we must be keen to learn and eager to understand what needs to be done for increasing the level of our knowledge, because Wisdom defeats Ignorance and sets us free.

    Thoughts create moods and mental fermentations leading to craving and to clinging or attachment.

    Thoughts have Intention as their origin and happiness as their Cause, that is why one needs Evaluation, because it allows to examine each thought and to understand if right or its truth.

    What truth?

    As Intention, if the thought is useful for our progress on the Noble Path.
    &
    As Cause, if the thought leads to a temporary happiness or to the supreme unshaking happiness of the Heart.

    This is the main distinction to personally always evaluate and then understand about each thought, because this distinction makes us abandon unuseful or harmful thoughts linked to the world and makes us see, choose & stick only to thoughts based on useful Intentions & Causes (taking to positive results), that need to be found and developed.

    One can learn from the Suttas like from a Teacher, however, one also has to look for their right explanation from different Monks.
    But in order to understand what?

    In order to understand at what step one is, what needs to be done and how to do it in order to progress smoothly and rightly, without jumping too high or too low, when not yet ready.

    In other words, we are the Teachers of ourselves, there is no other Teacher.

    However, we need to know what & how to evaluate and to know as beneficial and what & how to avoid or uproot as not beneficial, for our own progress on the Spiritual Path.

    That is what Teacher means, that we look for and find specific explanations from others practicing the same path, letting us clearly understand what we have to do and how.

    So, the Teachers can be found mainly in Suttas or in Monks, because they teach and show us how to become Teachers of ourselves in different ways, our task is to find & learn from them the more suitable way for us and for our own nature to overcome any difficulty through right discerning evaluation and through the wisdom coming from it.

    My suggestion is to concentrate all efforts in mindfulness and in keeping the mind in peace from any thought, this is the basis.

    Living in the present moment with a mind aware of its peace from thoughts is the result.

    A mind in peace can understand better and deeper, because Evaluation increases with the Concentration based on mindfulness.

    And when Impermanence is constantly evaluated and clearly found in anything, then changement is understood as the illusion and it is then found in everything.

    When the illusion is seen and understood, then stopping any clinging & craving for it becomes natural, as result the usual worldly happiness, that each of us looks for or craves for or clings to, it becomes fake, because clearly understood as the illusion that it is, since only & always based on the unwished changement and, then, void of any real fixed self.

    While the peace of mind itself becomes and it is understood as the unshakable real happiness, because not changing until a higher one is achieved through wisdom.

    We are all Teachers…

    The ones making us better evaluate ‘reality’ are Teachers, even if they do not teach something and just question us, because if their questions or actions lead to our better understanding of what or how to train in, then they become our Teachers.

    The real Teacher is our own Evaluation, at the beginning and in the middle and at the end, but in order to increase it we need external Teachers explaining or letting us understand how to do it.

    With Mudita, wishing to everyone to be aware and to increase Mindfulness & own Evaluation, leading both to the Truth and to Wisdom. 🙏❤️🙏

    Views: 2

  • The 3 Eternal Lights of the Heart

    The 3 Eternal Lights of the Heart

    The 3 LIGHTS of the Heart
    —
    This universe is made of the 6 Worlds of Samsara, with its Devas and Maras, it is based both on the 4 elements, originated from the nothingness, and on changement, that is why everything can be clearly seen just as an illusion, not real because without a self and always born from causes or conditions, only taking to Delusion or Dukkha.

    This universe, where the Truth or Dhamma is so rare to appear, it is a prison made by the own Ignorance and by the cravings coming from it, that only take to the Delusion of the expectations for any type of ‘own’ happiness.

    In this universe there are 3 LIGHTS, not born from causes or conditions and never changing nor finishing :

    1st Loving Kindness or Metta, taking to unity and to overcome division or any difference through purity of Heart

    2nd Wisdom or Panna of the Heart , the one that, when rightly trained, can defeat Ignorance, overcoming in this way the 6 lower Worlds of Samsara for reaching one of the 4 Higher Worlds or Nibbana.

    3rd the Dhamma, also called the only never changing Law of this universe, saying : “everything changes”, where Impermanence or Anicca and Not-Self or Anatta can be found.

    Because the Self cannot be found in anything inside this universe, any idea of Self is an illusion, since only and always based on both Dependent Origination or Karma and on continuous changement.

    Once the Self is understood as untrue, then the Not-Self can be discerned and used to overcome samsara through its unchanging Law and Truth, i.e. the Dhamma, that is only available when a Buddha appears and during His Dhamma-Wheel turning.

    This is my humble view of illusion and of reality…

    With Mudita i hope it may help others too, above all in taking the right decision and follow the only 3 real things in this universe.

    Views: 0

  • The 10 ways to Enlightment

    The 10 ways to Enlightment

    ENLIGHTMENT…
    &
    The 10 WAYS for achieving it…
    —
    There are 10 worlds or planes of existence, the first 6 are in samsara, while the other 4 are above it and without rebirth, that is why they are also called the deathless.

    How can one get to those 4 upper worlds void of any suffering caused by rebirth ?

    From my humble understanding there are different possibilities, according to each one’s nature and/or karma and/or right view/effort/resolve :

    1. Listening to a Dhamma talk on the 4 Noble Truths (Stream-Entry)

    2. Understanding the Dhamma through the right evaluation of Anatta (Dhamma-Eye)

    3. Training rightly in the 4 foundations of mindfulness (Samadhi-Bhavana)

    4. Using right discernment of the Dhamma, i.e. : Sampajanna (Khippabinna)

    5. Achieving any of the 4 Noble States through absorption or the liberation of heart (Brahmavihara-Bhavana)

    6. Right resolve/resolution concerning the future, both in human life as wife/son of a next Buddha for example or willingly choosing one of the upper worlds destinations (i.e. : Arahant, Bodhisattva, Buddha)

    7. Visiting Thusita and choosing it as next destination after the present human existence (Bodhisattva)

    8. Hiding from karma by its understanding/seed and by the right handling of intentions, in order not to be seen anymore by both Mara and Yama after human death (being Astute)

    9. Empathy based on gratitude, kind love and compassion, opening the gates of the spiritual path (Monks & Savakas)

    10. Boundless love, overcoming duality and any conceit linked to a self (Pacekkabuddhas)

    In my very limited knowledge, each one of the above 10 WAYS is valid/effective for ending forever the suffering of Samsara.

    The only difference is the time needed in achieving the goal, if in the present exsistence or if more rebirths are needed.

    Anyone seeing & wishing to end the suffering of Samara, should choose the one matching more his own nature, in order to step on ‘the path of the unshakable happiness’. 🙏✨🙏

    Views: 0

  • “Shifting Perspectives: Nurturing Wholesome Thoughts in the Cycle of Mindfulness”

    “Shifting Perspectives: Nurturing Wholesome Thoughts in the Cycle of Mindfulness”

    “Shifting Perspectives: Nurturing Wholesome Thoughts in the Cycle of Mindfulness”

    In our fast-paced world, we often seek closure and finality in various aspects of life. This pursuit is mirrored in the invention of the clock, a symbol of humanity’s quest for order and progression. However, it’s intriguing to consider that the invention of the clock might be the harbinger of both order and chaos. While the atomic bomb’s invention is widely regarded as a monumental turning point, the invention of the clock might bear even more significant consequences, reshaping our understanding of time and thought.

    The clock instills a notion of linear progression. A relentless march forward where our thoughts and actions must fit within the confines of this structured timeline. This concept is both a boon and a bane. On one hand, it propels us to accomplish goals and meet deadlines. Yet, it also creates the illusion that once our thoughts are redirected from unwholesome to wholesome, the clock’s hands move forward, and we’re on an uninterrupted journey into the future. In truth, life operates in cycles, and this realization unveils a deeper perspective on mindfulness.

    Cycles govern our existence in ways we often overlook. Just as we can fall back into old habits if we don’t actively cultivate change, we can lose skills we once mastered if we cease practicing. This applies not only to physical skills but also to the art of nurturing wholesome thoughts. A key point emerges: consistent practice is the bedrock of sustainable change. Arthur Rubinstein’s recognition that even at the peak of skill, practice remains essential holds a crucial lesson. Mindfulness is not a one-time feat; it’s an ongoing journey requiring constant nourishment.

    In this journey, the idea of urgency and emergencies takes on a new dimension. While societal norms push us to perceive urgency externally, the heart of urgency often rests within our emotional reactions. By discerning between true urgency and the urgency bred from our emotions, we unlock the power to respond wisely. This awareness ripples through our interactions, allowing us to face others’ negativity with empathy and tranquility.

    Central to this evolution is the practice of observation?of our thoughts, sensations, and emotions. This practice reveals the fleeting nature of these mental phenomena, aiding detachment and preventing their sway over us. This perspective shift permits us to pause, assess, and respond mindfully instead of reacting impulsively. This is the essence of mindfulness?cultivating a space between stimulus and response.

    Morning and nighttime become pivotal moments for this practice. By consciously tending to our thoughts before sleep and upon waking, we set the tone for our day. These moments of intention shape our mental landscape, transforming dread into contentment and anxiety into ease. Gradually, the art of steering our thoughts becomes second nature, fostering a sense of calm resilience.

    Yet, there’s no finish line in this journey. The fallacy of “arrival” permeates Western interpretations of Buddhism, obscuring the truth that practice is a constant companionship. Just as a child’s swing requires a gentle push to maintain momentum, our practice necessitates ongoing effort. Embracing this, we move beyond perfectionism and embrace the dance of progress.

    In closing, the journey of nurturing wholesome thoughts is a testament to the power of continuous cultivation. The clock’s hands might move inexorably forward, but our minds possess the agility to shift gears, steering us toward wisdom and serenity. As you persist in this journey, remember that each mindful breath, each redirecting thought, brings you closer to the profound liberation of self-discovery. Keep observing, keep nurturing, and keep evolving.

    Views: 2

  • here is the blog post:

    here is the blog post:

    <h6>here is the blog post: 
    
    As I continue to explore the intricacies of my practice, I've reached yet another inflection point. Recently, I've been reflecting on some of Dhammarato' s reiterated teachings, which focus on:
    1. Cultivating a feminine, nurturing nature
    2. Delving into Patticca Sammupada, specifically regarding the curation and manipulation of the data we receive
    By integrating these two aspects—embracing feminine nurturing through our thoughts and relaxing our bodies, and persistently curating our experiences to emphasize nurturing inputs—we can profoundly impact our daily experiences, leading to immense satisfaction.
    Interestingly, my recent foray into computer programming and the inner workings of large language models (LLMs) has shed light on the significance of the quality of training data they receive. It appears that the efficacy of AI models hinges not only on their size but also on the quality of the data they consume. The experiences we encounter when interacting with an LLM are determined by the data it has been trained on, which is a vast and diverse collection gathered from the internet. As the creators of these models strive to provide high-quality, interesting, and useful data, they employ experts in various fields to guide the model's learning and development.
    This aspect of AI models parallels our own
    human capabilities. We, too, possess the ability to discern and curate only the highest quality inputs for our incredibly efficient and adaptable AGI—our brains. What a remarkable gift this is.
    The Dhamma teaches us that we can curate data not only at the intellectual level but also by cultivating wholesome thoughts, such as those of a motherly nurturing nature. By doing so, we can give rise to feelings of safety, satisfaction, security, and success, all of which contribute to our overall well-being.
    As a board member of the Open Sangha Foundation (OSF), I'm eager to expand on these fascinating parallels between the human brain, the Dhamma, and AI in upcoming blog posts. The connections between our ability to curate data for personal growth and our ongoing exploration of AI models could provide valuable insights into the interplay between technology and spirituality. Ultimately, this understanding could help us harness our unique human capabilities and foster a more harmonious balance between our intellectual pursuits and mental well-being.

    </h6>

    Views: 2

  • Can “just say no” Be effective

    I think with time, practice, restraint, and discipline(and 8FNM) the practice of “Just say no” can be a good method.

    If it’s not working for u yet…don’t say no…just say later. Or not now.
    Let me see if I can wait 10 more mins and not do that behavior which is causing more suffering….and see if I can imagine being ok if I do it, or if I don’t. It’s okay either way.
    From that okayness saying no becomes easier. Cultivate good feelings and right action. Its also about what you do leading up to trying to Saying no to immaturely following sense desires…get some momentum with the easy “No’s” and then when the hard ones come you will have a stronger foundation to help u ride the wave.

    Views: 1

  • Join the discord!

    Join the discord to chat with other people on the path, ask questions and get answers; https://discord.gg/8ZZC7gyrYB

     

     

    (more…)

    Views: 2

  • Call the Buddha

    Call the Buddha

    The Buddhas phone number .

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zlCrpgpoBsM&t=674s

    875444

    1. 8 fold noble path
      7 factors of enlight
      5 Powers
    2. 5 faculties
    3. 4 foundations of mindfulness
    4. 4 basis of psychic power
    5. 4 right efforts

    Views: 2